Difference between revisions of "WMF UX Improvement Effort"

From Kiwix
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(update)
(new fields for priority and difficulty)
Line 1: Line 1:
{|{{Prettytable}}
{|{{Prettytable}}
! Task !! width="300px"| Title !! Description !! Next step !! Progress !! Bug
! Task !! width="300px"| Title !! Description !! Next step !! Progress !! Bug !! Priority !! Difficulty


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #0 || '''[[#Search in text improvement]]''' || We should merge search in text and search in ZIM and have nicer searchbar & search button. || proposal || 10% || [https://sourceforge.net/tracker/?func=detail&aid=3098294&group_id=175508&atid=873518]
| #0 || '''[[#Search in text improvement]]''' || We should merge search in text and search in ZIM and have nicer searchbar & search button. || proposal || 10% || [https://sourceforge.net/tracker/?func=detail&aid=3098294&group_id=175508&atid=873518] || ||


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #1 || '''[[#Bad MacOSX Quit menu item]]''' || MacOSX Quit menu item in File menu is odd to see || realization || 0% || [https://sourceforge.net/tracker/?func=detail&aid=3165259&group_id=175508&atid=873515]
| #1 || '''[[#Bad MacOSX Quit menu item]]''' || MacOSX Quit menu item in File menu is odd to see || realization || 0% || [https://sourceforge.net/tracker/?func=detail&aid=3165259&group_id=175508&atid=873515] || ||


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #2 || '''[[#Dead "adding content" link in the help]]''' || "Adding Content" paragraph does not exist in the Help page in English || realization || 0% || [https://sourceforge.net/tracker/?func=detail&aid=3165272&group_id=175508&atid=873515]
| #2 || '''[[#Dead "adding content" link in the help]]''' || "Adding Content" paragraph does not exist in the Help page in English || realization || 0% || [https://sourceforge.net/tracker/?func=detail&aid=3165272&group_id=175508&atid=873515] || ||


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #3 || '''[[#Revamp the help page]]''' || The help page must be more complete, more ''sexy'', with screenshots. It should also provide an easy way to download new content. || proposal || 0% ||  
| #3 || '''[[#Revamp the help page]]''' || The help page must be more complete, more ''sexy'', with screenshots. It should also provide an easy way to download new content. || proposal || 0% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #4 || '''[[#Download manager]]''' || For most of the user, this is too complicated to download separately the content. The download must be integrated in Kiwix itself || realization || 20% ||  
| #4 || '''[[#Download manager]]''' || For most of the user, this is too complicated to download separately the content. The download must be integrated in Kiwix itself || realization || 20% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #5 || '''[[#Google-styled search result page]]''' || Displaying the results in the sidebar is not good. We should display the results like google in a tab. || realisation || 10% ||  
| #5 || '''[[#Google-styled search result page]]''' || Displaying the results in the sidebar is not good. We should display the results like google in a tab. || realisation || 10% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #6 || '''[[#Localization improvement]]''' || Kiwix has too few locales and it is too complicated to update them. || realisation || 30% ||  
| #6 || '''[[#Localization improvement]]''' || Kiwix has too few locales and it is too complicated to update them. || realisation || 30% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #7 || '''[[#ESC to quit Fullscreen]]''' || This should be possible to press ESC to qui the fullscreen. || closed || 100% ||  
| #7 || '''[[#ESC to quit Fullscreen]]''' || This should be possible to press ESC to qui the fullscreen. || closed || 100% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #8 || '''[[#User unfriendly index dialogbox]]''' || Change the invitation to index message to "This file does not include a search index. Creating one may take several minutes. Do you want to index your ZIM file now?". || closed || 100% ||  
| #8 || '''[[#User unfriendly index dialogbox]]''' || Change the invitation to index message to "This file does not include a search index. Creating one may take several minutes. Do you want to index your ZIM file now?". || closed || 100% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #9 || '''[[#Search misses some articles]]''' || Some articles included in the Wikipedia Version 0.5 ZIM file I tested were not matched by searching and could only be viewed by clicking a link to them. || closed || 100% ||  
| #9 || '''[[#Search misses some articles]]''' || Some articles included in the Wikipedia Version 0.5 ZIM file I tested were not matched by searching and could only be viewed by clicking a link to them. || closed || 100% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #10 || '''[[#Unnecessary doubleclick by suggestions]]''' || If a match is chosen from the pop-up search suggestions, it should probably go ahead and execute that search rather than waiting for the user to hit enter. || realization || 0% ||  
| #10 || '''[[#Unnecessary doubleclick by suggestions]]''' || If a match is chosen from the pop-up search suggestions, it should probably go ahead and execute that search rather than waiting for the user to hit enter. || realization || 0% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #11 || '''[[#Desktop File browser integration]]''' || ZIM file mime-type should be recognized as "application/x-zim", icon should be the kiwix one and double click on them should start kiwix and open the file. || realization || 30% ||  
| #11 || '''[[#Desktop File browser integration]]''' || ZIM file mime-type should be recognized as "application/x-zim", icon should be the kiwix one and double click on them should start kiwix and open the file. || realization || 30% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #12 || '''[[#non-functional search icon in toolbar]]''' || Seems to be non-functional. || reprocase || 0% ||  
| #12 || '''[[#non-functional search icon in toolbar]]''' || Seems to be non-functional. || reprocase || 0% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #13 || '''[[#Bad "transliteration" menuitem on OSX]]''' ||  || realization || 0% || [https://sourceforge.net/tracker/?func=detail&aid=3167823&group_id=175508&atid=873515]
| #13 || '''[[#Bad "transliteration" menuitem on OSX]]''' ||  || realization || 0% || [https://sourceforge.net/tracker/?func=detail&aid=3167823&group_id=175508&atid=873515] || ||


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #14 || '''[[#Unusual keyboard shortcuts on OSX]]''' || In the Mac version, the Keyboard shortcuts are not typical for a Mac application (normally the Command key is used rather than Control). Regardless, they do not actually work using either keys. || realization || 0% ||  
| #14 || '''[[#Unusual keyboard shortcuts on OSX]]''' || In the Mac version, the Keyboard shortcuts are not typical for a Mac application (normally the Command key is used rather than Control). Regardless, they do not actually work using either keys. || realization || 0% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #15 || '''[[#History navigator]]''' || You can purge your history, but you can't view it. It would be nice to be able to browse through your history either from a menu or the Sidebar.. || discussion || 0% ||  
| #15 || '''[[#History navigator]]''' || You can purge your history, but you can't view it. It would be nice to be able to browse through your history either from a menu or the Sidebar.. || discussion || 0% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #16 || '''[[#Back button wrong behaviour]]''' ||While it was indexing, I decided to try clicking some article links. This worked fine, although I was not able to return to the home page by using the back button. (Strangely this only happened the first time I left the home page. On subsequent attempts I was able to go back to the home page by clicking the back button.) || reprocase || 0% ||  
| #16 || '''[[#Back button wrong behaviour]]''' ||While it was indexing, I decided to try clicking some article links. This worked fine, although I was not able to return to the home page by using the back button. (Strangely this only happened the first time I left the home page. On subsequent attempts I was able to go back to the home page by clicking the back button.) || reprocase || 0% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #16 || '''[[#Preferences dialog box]]''' || It might be nice to have a preferences pane where you could set things like "Always show the tab bar", "Remember browsing history", etc.  || realization || 20% ||  
| #16 || '''[[#Preferences dialog box]]''' || It might be nice to have a preferences pane where you could set things like "Always show the tab bar", "Remember browsing history", etc.  || realization || 20% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #16 || '''[[#Kiosk mode]]''' || It would also be cool to have a kiosk mode available in which the interface would be fullscreen unless a special keyboard command was issued. || discussion || 0% ||  
| #16 || '''[[#Kiosk mode]]''' || It would also be cool to have a kiosk mode available in which the interface would be fullscreen unless a special keyboard command was issued. || discussion || 0% || || ||  


|- style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="vertical-align: top;"
| #16 || '''[[#DNS prefetching]]''' || although this isn't a user interface issue, it seems that Kiwix makes DNS requests on all the external links included in each Wikipedia article it loads (without clicking on them). So if I pull up World War II, for example, Kiwix might make a couple hundred DNS requests. This isn't bad for someone living in the US, but if you are in a remote area and don't have unlimited data for free, it could be an unexpected surprise, since Kiwix is supposed to be an "offline" reader. Just thought I would pass it along. || closed || 100% ||  
| #16 || '''[[#DNS prefetching]]''' || although this isn't a user interface issue, it seems that Kiwix makes DNS requests on all the external links included in each Wikipedia article it loads (without clicking on them). So if I pull up World War II, for example, Kiwix might make a couple hundred DNS requests. This isn't bad for someone living in the US, but if you are in a remote area and don't have unlimited data for free, it could be an unexpected surprise, since Kiwix is supposed to be an "offline" reader. Just thought I would pass it along. || closed || 100% || || ||  


|}
|}

Revision as of 21:39, 1 March 2011

Task Title Description Next step Progress Bug Priority Difficulty
#0 #Search in text improvement We should merge search in text and search in ZIM and have nicer searchbar & search button. proposal 10% [1]
#1 #Bad MacOSX Quit menu item MacOSX Quit menu item in File menu is odd to see realization 0% [2]
#2 #Dead "adding content" link in the help "Adding Content" paragraph does not exist in the Help page in English realization 0% [3]
#3 #Revamp the help page The help page must be more complete, more sexy, with screenshots. It should also provide an easy way to download new content. proposal 0%
#4 #Download manager For most of the user, this is too complicated to download separately the content. The download must be integrated in Kiwix itself realization 20%
#5 #Google-styled search result page Displaying the results in the sidebar is not good. We should display the results like google in a tab. realisation 10%
#6 #Localization improvement Kiwix has too few locales and it is too complicated to update them. realisation 30%
#7 #ESC to quit Fullscreen This should be possible to press ESC to qui the fullscreen. closed 100%
#8 #User unfriendly index dialogbox Change the invitation to index message to "This file does not include a search index. Creating one may take several minutes. Do you want to index your ZIM file now?". closed 100%
#9 #Search misses some articles Some articles included in the Wikipedia Version 0.5 ZIM file I tested were not matched by searching and could only be viewed by clicking a link to them. closed 100%
#10 #Unnecessary doubleclick by suggestions If a match is chosen from the pop-up search suggestions, it should probably go ahead and execute that search rather than waiting for the user to hit enter. realization 0%
#11 #Desktop File browser integration ZIM file mime-type should be recognized as "application/x-zim", icon should be the kiwix one and double click on them should start kiwix and open the file. realization 30%
#12 #non-functional search icon in toolbar Seems to be non-functional. reprocase 0%
#13 #Bad "transliteration" menuitem on OSX realization 0% [4]
#14 #Unusual keyboard shortcuts on OSX In the Mac version, the Keyboard shortcuts are not typical for a Mac application (normally the Command key is used rather than Control). Regardless, they do not actually work using either keys. realization 0%
#15 #History navigator You can purge your history, but you can't view it. It would be nice to be able to browse through your history either from a menu or the Sidebar.. discussion 0%
#16 #Back button wrong behaviour While it was indexing, I decided to try clicking some article links. This worked fine, although I was not able to return to the home page by using the back button. (Strangely this only happened the first time I left the home page. On subsequent attempts I was able to go back to the home page by clicking the back button.) reprocase 0%
#16 #Preferences dialog box It might be nice to have a preferences pane where you could set things like "Always show the tab bar", "Remember browsing history", etc. realization 20%
#16 #Kiosk mode It would also be cool to have a kiosk mode available in which the interface would be fullscreen unless a special keyboard command was issued. discussion 0%
#16 #DNS prefetching although this isn't a user interface issue, it seems that Kiwix makes DNS requests on all the external links included in each Wikipedia article it loads (without clicking on them). So if I pull up World War II, for example, Kiwix might make a couple hundred DNS requests. This isn't bad for someone living in the US, but if you are in a remote area and don't have unlimited data for free, it could be an unexpected surprise, since Kiwix is supposed to be an "offline" reader. Just thought I would pass it along. closed 100%


Search in text improvement

There is also a small bug: If the search term is not found, it returns an error saying "[JavaScript Application] The text you entered was not found." The "[JavaScript Application]" part should probably be removed or replaced. Ryan

Bad MacOSX Quit menu item

Dead "adding content" link in the help

Revamp the help page

Download manager

Google-styled search result page

As previously discussed, Google-style search results would be a nice alternative to the current Sidebar implementation, especially if it could include a brief snippet from each article. Perhaps you could configure what type of search you prefer from a preferences menu. Ryan

Localization improvement

We will migration to translatewiki.net. We know how to make the migration, I still need to work on the migraation scripts, new templates and import scripts. Kelson 13:02, 26 February 2011 (UTC)

ESC to quit Fullscreen

User unfriendly index dialogbox

Search misses some articles

Unnecessary doubleclick by suggestions

Desktop File browser integration

Gnome done, OSX, KDE and Windows still to do. Kelson 14:12, 26 February 2011 (UTC)

non-functional search icon in toolbar

Bad "transliteration" menuitem on OSX

Unusual keyboard shortcuts on OSX

History navigator

Back button wrong behaviour

Preferences dialog box

Kiosk mode

DNS prefetching

See also